|
Global TMW:
|
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
Most Commented On
Archives
Blog
Link This | Email this | Blog This | Comments (8)
Handheld oscilloscope evaluationsMay 14, 2007For the past two weeks, I've been evaluating four handheld oscilloscopes. They are:
* AEMC OX 7104-C (Go to the review)
Tomorrow, I'll begin reporting my results, starting with AEMC. I hope to post one evaluation each day this week. I'm just waiting for a computer upgrade to complete the software evaluations. Fluke will follow AEMC. Agilent and Protek will come out together for reasons that will be made clear. To perform the evaluations, I used an Agilent 33220A, a 20-MHz function generator that Agilent provided without my asking. After posting the oscilloscope reviews, I'll post a review of the 33220A. I'll also post a table of oscilloscope features that I consider important. Often, what makes a difference in the purchase of an instrument isn't the banner features, but rather the little things. For example, the ease of changing the battery or ease in viewing the screen outdoors can sway decision. Size and weight matter, too. Posted by Martin Rowe on May 14, 2007 | Comments (8) Industries: Bench and Modular Instrumentation
June 4, 2007
In response to: Handheld oscilloscope evaluations tech commented: Thanks for doing this review.
June 7, 2007
In response to: Handheld oscilloscope evaluations Martin Rowe commented: In response to tech's comment: If you're accustomed to analog scopes, then you probably want dedicated buttons for vertical and horizontal scales. Only the Protek handheld scope lacks these buttons. Agilent is comparatively priced to Protek (Read reviews of both because they are very similar), with Fluke nearly doub the price and AEMC nearly double that. However, there are plenty of small bench scopes in that price range now, too.
June 7, 2007
In response to: Handheld oscilloscope evaluations Tony in SV commented: I do some industrial automation troubleshooting, and own both a Tek THS720 and a Fluke 199 (older monochrome version). The Tek has more of an traditional scope feel to it.
October 13, 2007
In response to: Handheld oscilloscope evaluations tech commented: After some more consideration, we found another solution. We went for the Tektronix TPS2024. It is battery powered, small and lightweight, with 4 isolated channels, isolated trigger, and set up like a traditional scope. The back lighted buttons are nice as well. It also has a Power Bundle (probe & software) option that makes for a very well rounded Industrial troubleshooting tool. I would recommend that you take a look. I think that readers who were interested in the handheld scope reviews would be interested in a proper review of this tool as well. Thanks Tony for pointing out the importance of isolated channels - it helped in making our decision.
October 30, 2007
In response to: Handheld oscilloscope evaluations EmbeddedFlyer commented: I have a few things to add... First, it's a little sad that Agilent (a company that makes some great higher-end scopes) has taken to slapping their name on an offbrand product also sold by Protek? I have an older Protek handheld scope and it's nearly worthless. The Agilent and Protek do NOT have isolated inputs. Neither do the new HDS series handheld scopes from Owon. Only the DMM inputs are isolated. The Tek TPS2000 series is indeed easy to use, and has isolated inputs, but for a relatively new design they have rather poor recording depth, limited features and limited display resolution. For about the same price as the TPS2012, the Fluke 196C offers a better display, more triggering options, more measurement options, data logging, DMM functionality in a much more rugged field-friendly package. If you don't need isolated inputs, get an Instek. The GDS-2012 blows away the Tek TPS-2012 for half the price with USB, deeper memory and more although the battery is optional.
November 12, 2007
In response to: Handheld oscilloscope evaluations NAVICPMart employee commented: If you work for the Federal government or military, the Fluke 199C is availble at a great price through www.navicpmart.com
January 30, 2008
In response to: Handheld oscilloscope evaluations Evan C commented: I can say the most popular unit that we sell is the Fluke 199c/003s scopemeter. Our Instek scopes give you a great bank for the buck. Try us at www.tequipment.net
October 25, 2008
In response to: Handheld oscilloscope evaluations Manu Singh commented: I'm trying to find a suitable DSO for home use in the $1500ish range. I looked at the LeCroy WaveAce and Instek GDS-2012 scopes, both are very competitively priced and feature similar capabilities. However, a unit like the Protek 860 which has both a 60MHz x 2 DSO and a full featured DMM (temp, capacitance, etc.) with full datalogging and PC connectivity seems like a good deal. I'm mostly fixing home electronics, radio control stuff, and probing automotive electronics. Is it made in China?
Advertisement
|
Advertisements
|
|
|
|